I really like reading this meme, because you know more tv than anyone I know. :) I agree about Glee. I was kind of skeptical when it first started because Ryan Murphy was producing and look what he did with Nip/Tuck. That show started off interesting and I had to stop watching when it just became too ridiculous.... crazy plots (husband kills their dog because he figured out that wife was letting dog give her oral sex by spreading peanut butter on her genitals--- WTF? on a plastic surgery show?) and no character continuity. So I think it's a Ryan Murphy thing. I really liked the first two seasons of Glee, but now I can't even watch it anymore because of all it's WTFness.

Also, loved the first season of Heroes, and then yes... the second season was like a whole different show.

The shows I am really, really loving now are both on FX--- Justified and the Americans. You should watch if you can.